lesson
A counterargument deserves a fair answer
1 · Learn
An argument states a position, supports it and considers relevant objections. For a fictional school garden proposal, benefits might include growing space while concerns might include cost and accessible routes. Label invented examples as examples, not survey evidence.
A balanced response does not have to give every claim equal weight. It should represent an objection accurately and explain a reasoned response without attacking the person who raised it.
2 · Worked example
I write, 'A garden could support plant study, but the plan must keep the path clear.' This acknowledges a real design concern rather than claiming everyone who objects dislikes plants.
3 · Your turn
Write a fair response to 'The beds may block the path' without inventing a completed safety assessment.
Check your answer
Example: 'That is a valid concern. The plan should be measured and reviewed so the path stays accessible before any beds are installed.'
4 · Apply your learning
Draft a short proposal and underline claims that need evidence before they can be stated as facts.
Adult guidance and safety
Read the supplied text together if needed. Accept well-supported alternative interpretations, not invented evidence. Use wider whole books, poems and plays alongside these short original models; provide specific feedback on writing and revisit spelling over time.
Open your writing and drawing pad
Write, draw or show your working. Use a mouse, pen or finger. This pad is not a submitted answer.
Not saved to your account. Download your drawing as PNG and your typed notes as TXT before leaving or refreshing. They are separate files. Do not enter private information.
Open a picture saved on this device to draw on it again. Opening replaces the drawing, but Undo can restore it. PNG only, up to 4 MB and 4096 × 4096 pixels. The picture stays in this browser; it is not uploaded. Paper lines in a saved picture become part of that picture.
Clear the drawing? Your typed notes will stay. You can undo this action.
Your pad is empty.
Open a UTF-8 TXT file from this device, up to 40 KB and 10,000 characters. It stays in this browser. Opening can be undone until you type again. Downloads keep a new copy; they do not change the file you opened.
Replace the notes on this page with the opened file? Download the current notes first if you want to keep them.
Typed notes are not submitted answers.
Practice this lesson
Lesson resources
Browse the available practice activities and worksheets for this lesson.
Your progress